Recent Comments By EJ / USA
BRIAN said to me (can't remember when, but I just re-read this) [see the Top 20] - regarding the rate of infant mortality in the US versus other parts of the world:
""Also realize that you are treading on one-dimensional thinking again, such as pointing out infant mortality rates without bothering to do some research as to possible reasons. For example, in an article explaining why Cuba has better infant mortality rates, the following provides insight I'm sure you didn't bother researching: "The result is that the statistics make it appear as if Cuba's infant mortality rate is significantly better than the United States', but in fact what is really being measured in this difference is that the United States takes far more serious (and expensive) interventions among extremely low birth weight and extremely premature infants than Cuba (or much of the rest of the world for that matter) does." http://www.overpopulation.com/articles/2002/000019.html
This is my response:
There is a book of statistics published by "The Economist", called "World in Figures".
Please consult the section "Lowest Infant Mortality" : there are 26 country listed. The USA is not listed there. Shouldn't the USA with its costly medical research etc, be at least number 26 or better? Don't you think the fact that there is no Universal Healthcare in the US has anything to do with this?
   
(1074 votes)
To Ted: you are a good example of why foreigners have a bad impression of Americans! And what's more, it is always ignorant people who are the most vocal. Don't you think that the 52 or so % who re-elected Bush are idiots and ignorant and arrogant? That's a pretty amazing number.
Saying the Germans are this, the French that, etc., is just the same rhetoric that you comdemn from foreigners.
To the person who thinks China will crumble: China holds the biggest part of America's debt. They just need to ask for payment, and the USA crumbles.
All big empires crumbled before, and this one will also.
Regarding elections, as Stalin said: it is not who votes that counts, it is who counts the votes. And please, people, don't crown Obama, before he has even started, to be the greatest president. I voted for him myself, but I wait to see. There is a big machine called the "System" and few wonderful people have beaten this system. Large corporations, multinationals, are part of this system. So let's see what they allow Obama to do.
I praise this site for letting people debate their point of view in a respectful manner and criticizing it as anti-American is just plain stupid. Discussion has not always solved everything but conflicts or wars certainly don't. You'd think people and governments would have learned by now.
To all, at Berkshire and online, have a Merry Christmas, Kwanza, Solstice, or whatever Holiday you honor, and a Happy New Year (which everyone on earth does celebrates).
   
(1088 votes)
To everyone who wonders why so many "foreigners" here become citizens?:
It is not because we love it here so much.
It is simply because the government TAXES YOU 60% if your spouse dies. If you are an American couple, you inherit your spouse's money TAX-FREE.
The government is worried the surviving spouse will take her/his money and go back home without paying taxes.
Now, when you become an American citizen, and you wish to go back home to retire, even if you renounce your American citizenship, you will have to file your taxes with the US for the next 10 years.
And let's say you go to live in a country without taxes, like Saoudi Arabia for instance, you will pay US taxes, even though you don't use US services, like roads, etc.
A little information that is good to know...
   
(1244 votes)
Anyone who wants to know more about what the US governments have been doing all along should read: "A People's history of the United States".
Do not assume that the US has not secretly interfered into other countries governments, elections, coups, etc., and for a very very long time.
Read also a book called: "Confessions of an Economic Hitman," by John Perkins It is pretty edifying.
People can't just make their minds up solely with what school "history" teaches, nor with the newspapers (all owned by big corporations and where journalists are not free to "tell it as it is". (For example, in a magazine, if you write an article - say where you criticize "milk" for instance - the editor will pull your article, because an advertiser in the milk industry won't like it and will drop its support of the magazine. Some might remember the big hoopla caused by Oprah when she said she would not eat another burger: she got the Meat Industry to slap her with a law suit.
This happens also with political criticisms if it doesn't agree with the views of the owner of the paper).
You must read, read a lot, all sides, and then make up your mind. Americans are very poorly educated in high schools, and college Degrees offer a good specialized education, but not a 'complete' education.
Lots of Americans are nice, but lots are so gullible that they act like sheep and follow the leaders, right or wrong. They affirm lots of opinions without knowing anything about them, just they heard it said and liked the sound of it.
   
(2119 votes)
YurokJames, you are very wise. What you say is right on.
Also, here is something I just found that Gore Vidal said recently:
"GORE VIDAL: Well, there are many odious traits that Americans have that the rest of the world doesn’t like. Constant boasting with not much to boast about, that gets on other people’s nerves. The idea that, somehow or other, the whole world belongs to us and everybody should do what we tell them to do, they don’t really like that. Weird, but they don’t. There has never been a people less suited for world dominion than the Americans of the twentieth century and twenty-first century.
Henry James was very good on that subject. "
   
(2045 votes)
To anybody, like Michel, who wants to know more, here is another book I recommend:
DISCOVERING AMERICA AS IT IS, by Valdas Anelauskas.
Valdas was a dissident journalist in the Soviet Union and was expelled and came to America in 1989, with the help of the Tolstoy Fundation, 10 years later than me. Also like me he then felt like a "naive victim of American propaganda".
I have only started the book and am looking forward to reading how he contemplates the future. Going back home is not always possible. It makes me so mad when some idiot screams, "if you don't like it here, why don't you leave", like an order. A lot of decisions are irreversible.
   
(2099 votes)
To Michel, France:
If you are interested in who governs really here, try to get your hand on this book: "9/11 and American Empire - Intellectuals Speak out", edited by David Ray Griffin and Peter Dale Scott. I especially recommend the last 3 chapters, and in particular the last one, ch.11, and its appendix with the names of important organisations and a list of the Key Players in American Politics. I counted them at 237 people +/- one or 2. They must nearly all support AIPAC although only one is listed as doing so. See who they work for, also! That is the real government of this country.
Nothing will change with the next "chosen" president.
Also, I see you can still buy an old French book by Claude Julien, "L'Empire Americain", publie par Grasset! (1968).
I wrote a note inside the cover after I read it in the early 80s, that says: "If I had read this in 1978, I would never, never, have come here. N.E.V.E.R."
Good reading.
   
(2328 votes)
MT and Nate are the smart, informed, Americans. This site has waited a long time for them.
There is a lot of talks right now on TV, radio (npr) and press about the Super Delegates and their effect on the elections in America. They were at it since the foundation of this country, but only now do I finally realize that it does not matter who you vote for, the Super Delegates decide everything. There is a book that came out last year without much fanfare. It is called "STEAL THIS VOTE - DIRTY ELECTIONS AND THE ROTTEN HISTORY OF DEMOCRACY IN AMERICA" by Andrew Gumbel. It is worth reading to learn how the voting is manipulated and how many people employ themselves to corrupt the system. On Morning Edition on NPR in the last week there was this Super Delegate from Utah where Obama wan the primaries and she was wondering who she was going to represent, Clinton or Obama: a dear friend wanted her to vote for Obama, but her mother wants her to vote for Clinton! So the Utah voters's voice does not count for anything? She has not made up her mind. So the Democrat candidate to face McCain will be elcted by +/- 980 Super Delegates (Congressmen, corporate CEOs, and other people who return favors).
Beautiful Democracy! And we criticize Mugabe in Zimbabwe?? Or Venezuela? etc. etc. What a role model...sometimes having been called the beacon of democracy.
Will I ever vote again? I sincerely don't know. Stalin said it is not who votes that counts, it is who count the votes.
   
(2245 votes)
Michael Dailey: read this:
Can the US today really compare with Czechoslovakia in 1975?Tim Dowling The Guardian, Thursday March 13 2008
Nine-times Wimbledon champion Martina Navratilova has retaken Czech citizenship, which she lost when she defected from the former Czechoslovakia as an 18-year-old. Although she intends to retain her US citizenship, last year she told a Czech newspaper that she was now as ashamed of George Bush's America as she once was of the communist regime of her homeland. "The thing is, we elected Bush," she said. "That is worse! Against that, nobody chose a communist government in Czechoslovakia."
Strong words, but can one really compare the Czechoslovakia of 1975 with the United States of today?
Czechoslovakia, 1975: Despite widespread discontent with the oppressive Husak regime, a 1974 study finds active support for the government in 15% of the population, identified as pensioners, party bureaucrats, careerists, "parasites", extremist ideologues and persons involved in the Stalinist repression who fear that liberalisation might force them to account for their crimes.
US, 2008: George Bush's approval ratings generally hover around 30%, although one recent poll put it as low as 19%.
Czechoslovakia, 1975: Free healthcare available to all citizens.
US, 2008: 47 million Americans (16% of the population) have no health insurance. Another 16 million are "underinsured".
Czechoslovakia, 1975: Despite an increased standard of living and the widespread availability of material goods, consumerism is failing to placate a population fed up with draconian political controls.
US, 2008: Despite a rise in the cost of living, consumerism continues to placate a population largely oblivious to the curtailment of its freedoms.
Czechoslovakia, 1975: Growth of "net material product" is at an annual average of 5.7%, exceeding the target rate of 5.1% set out in the fifth Five-Year Plan. Full employment.
US, 2008: Energy Information Administration this week predicted negative growth in the two forthcoming financial quarters, the official definition of recession. 101,000 private-sector jobs were lost in February alone.
Czechoslovakia, 1975: The granting of visas to foreigners is "arbitrary", with denials justified under the "defence of national security", according to dissidents.
US, 2008: The American government uses the Patriot Act to bar entry to foreign visitors on the basis of ideology, according to the American Civil Liberties Union.
Czechoslovakia, 1975: Torture, though not officially sanctioned, has become a covert tool of state policy.
US, 2008: Torture officially sanctioned.
   
(2213 votes)
According to Michael Dailey:
"anyone has availibility to food, shelter, clothing and healthcare... no matter what"
???
Go to: http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/02/28/60minutes/main3889496.shtml
and see for yourselves? It takes 10 minutes and it is worth it. Many people live in their cars, eat from trash bins (Los Angeles Times last week), get charity clothing, as for healthcare, it is just a shame.
   
(2218 votes)
Have just seen Philippine de Dalle comment, to which I respond here:
Philippine, have you asked Canada and Mexico how they would like to add so many people who voted for Bush twice, to their own society. That is a lot of "idiots du village" to add to their own.
Otherwise, I am with you sister!
   
(2384 votes)
Thanks Yono, Happy New Year to you too, and to the World.
To Uncle Sam (USA): in 200 years, how many wars has the USA waged (and so many lost), and add a bloody civil war. Just put into your heads that you are no better than anybody else. At least recognize this and stop your self-aggrandisement. Be a little more modest, a little more benevolent and stop looting the rest of the world, then perhaps, the rest of the world won't hate you all so much.
   
(2304 votes)
dbowman: That's it? Are you finished and do you feel better? Good. You can go shine your shoes now!
Geez, lighten up fellow! Can't take criticism can you? At least it is on a site you do not HAVE to visit. It is not on thousands of bumper stickers that get in your face as you drive everyday, like all these anti-French ones that sprouted all over in 2003 and are still stuck on their car-bums. Nice little americans can do no wrong... so why are you hated so? All over the world, not just by Europeans. Get introspective and read a good book on the History of America.
Did you read, this weekend, about all these Indian doctors (hundreds) leaving America and very high salaries to go back to India to practice medicine there for 30,000$ a year. Obviously there must be a reason, no? And they are not Europeans either.
   
(2810 votes)
Kathleen:
My daughter spoke English, German, Dutch and French when she came to the USA age 11. In High School she learned Russian and Chinese which she continued in College. And we have Russian and Chinese friends and she can talk with them in their language. All right she is language gifted, but High Schools do offer language classes and so do Universities if you are interested in other people and other nations' culture. Just stop admiring your navel.
   
(2409 votes)
To (most) Americans visiting this site:
As I understand it, this is "Love US Hate US - what the world think of America". Obviously calling for foreigners to state what they think of this country and its people, places, etc. If it was "what the world thinks about Russia", or, lets be current: "what the world thinks about Iran" (haha), WHAT DO YOU THINK YOU-ALL WOULD BE SAYING ON THAT SITE THEN???
Another idea: let's talk about states: California versus New York or Illinois. That would be interesting wouldn't it? Do you think the Californians would be all that charming about the New Yorkers? I can tell you I live in California, and I find the New Yorkers who visit here quite rude and loud and sooo selfish. In fact I have some neighbors who moved here who are New Yorkers and are absolutely in everyone's face. A person took a parking space I was waiting for once last year and you know what he said to me afterward: "I am from New York - N-E-W-Y-O-R-K and I f--- you!". Nice, hey??? (Actually it is very funny).
So, you see: If you ask, you will get.... If it bothers you that much to read criticism, don't come here then. If you do, learn from it. Arrogance is not nice. That is what nationalism brings. It is universal.
   
(2592 votes)
I do not like my home country better than any other. I am not patriotic. I have lived in quite a few other countries before coming here. I feel more like a citizen of the world. No particular attachment, no particular allegiance. I actually very much dislike any blind patriotic displays, such as pledges, flags, etc.
I came to the USA in 1979, very enthusiastically, with my family, as my husband was transferred here for his job. Disillusion came quickly. By 1981 I was desparate to go back, to anywhere else - not my own country necessarily - I would have been happy to go to any continent. But my husband's job was in the balance and we were not all that young anymore to start over. (Also my husband is of a different nationality than me, from a country which has more affinities with this one). He had already invested many years in his company by then. We always thought we would move back somewhere in Europe when he retired. By then, it was too late for us. Our children are established here now. Grandkids.
In nearly 30 years, countries in Europe have changed, habits, places, ways of doing things are all different and we would have to adapt to all this newness at our age when it is difficult to change. But that really does not mean we enjoy it more here than if we had not come in the first place. In fact I dislike life here more and more, to the point where I do not wish to go and meet new people. I read a lot. I take care of my garden. We do go out and have foreign friends, who do not like it here either and we all tend to "find" each other somehow!
My feeling is that I have acquired a knowledge of this country that would be valuable if I could use it, but in doing so, I have ruined a part of my own life. My children are pretty happy here: they don't remember much else for comparison. I say part of my life only because this is not something I think about most of my time. We do do things we could be doing anywhere in the world here. One has to live somewhere, no?
Why is it that Americans cannot take criticism? My own opinion on this is that since infancy they have been fed propaganda on a large scale. History books in schools don't tell the real story and never tell other peoples' story. US kids grow up thinking everyone in the world is American! When they finally discover there are others, they imagine them as savages, and when they are grown up they make it their mission to "teach" the world.
It would be so interesting for American people visiting this site to have an open mind to what others have to say of their perception here or from abroad. Instead it is another battle front. Why is it that Americans are so confrontational, so allergic to criticism? I think it is because they are so insular. In Europe's many countries, children travel at an early age to each others countries, learn languages and the history and customs of these countries. They know other people don't do things the same way or think the same thing. They may laugh but they accept it.
Also Europe has seen many wars between these countries and they dislike war. In America "war is a word that gives us meaning" (part of the title of a book). War on drugs, war on poverty, war on terrorism, war on smoking etc. America has never had an invasion war. Its inhabitant have never gone through being invaded or bombed and having to live for years on rutabagas. It has had a bloody civil war but that was so long ago. Yet the re-creation of battles each year baffle me. People seem to enjoy war.
That is all I have to say, little C23.
   
(2488 votes)
Hey Anon, America is not "at the center of the buzz". This is a site about "love it or hate it" discourse, for people to give their opinion. That sure does not mean the rest of the World is so preoccupied with America. I can tell you billions (out of the 6) never have even a thought-a-day for America. Don't go and think you are the navel of the globe! But keep your eyes and your ears open and learn a thing or two. You need it badly.
   
(2714 votes)
America "lost" the world's support and sympathy when american people re-elected President Bush. That was unforgivable.
And now the Democrats won't impeach him, far less try him and his cohort.
Also, don't forget that Cheney was/is really in charge, with Rove.
   
(3356 votes)
"People like EJ", who are American citizens do not all feel American. So why should I bother to want to "improve" America. That is something uniquely American that if you don't like it you should do something to improve it or leave it. People have the freedom to live where they want and criticize how much they want. There are some countries without that freedom, but not in the First World. There are sites in other countries, called forums, and if you speak foreign languages you can go there and put in your grain of salt. (Go to Watching America site - most sites will accept your English language comment). In all the countries I lived in, people - including their citizens -would criticize the way things worked there, not least the American expats, who found European countries so unlikable that they re-create their own closed society overseas even including their own Cub Scout troops! (and they don't learn the language of the country they live in). But a big difference is that the rest of the world knows what goes on in America, but Americans do not know what goes on elsewhere.
"Tout le monde il est beau, tout le monde il est joli"! American optimism at all cost does not do it for me. I don't give a fig about America rushing downhill in a handbasket. The faster they get there the better.
Everything they do is always for their own benefit, in the guise of altruism! They have interfered with elections in every country in the world, including all the European countries' elections and the various labor groups, like in 1947 for instance in France.
American Imperialism started way back in the 19th century with President McKinley. And it hides behind the mask of idealism. Look what they have done with Iraq! And Iran before that, starting after the democratic election of Mossadegh. Yes, he was democratically elected but that did not please the Americans so they did a coup.
I wish people would research history and not gobble unquestioningly the pablum their schoolbooks (or newspapers) offer them. With the access to information now, through the Internet, lots of people throughout the world find out the reality behind America.
"America, my country right or wrong" sure rings funny. This is the most absurd quote in the American lore.
   
(2950 votes)
A great book to read everybody: "The little girl and the cigarette", by Benoit Duteurtre. It is a quick read: one afternoon, but it will give you a lasting impression of the absurdity of this society! I would not say "Wildly funny" as Melville House Publishing says it is. It is sarcastique and to the point. Get one and pass it around.
After close to 28 years here and following politics and reading avidly, I would not call this country a great country, (you, from the Netherland, how long have you spent here?). I think the Great Democratic Experiment has totally failed. And not starting with Bush, it already was around WWII and has been downhill ever since.
What a bunch of gullible people. They do not deserve Democracy with a big D. Corruption everywhere, like in a banana republic. Just take a look at what Schwarzenegger is up to right now: placing all his buddies from 1968 when he arrived here and onwards, in charge of committees for which they have no clues. hahaha. "Caulifornia" is like a banana republic in another bigger one.
really
   
(2987 votes)
|